Monthly Archives: November 2009

Listening to the fridge

I’ve been distracted from the ’stages’ and before moving on to stage 3, I want to share a little about the experience of being left behind by someone who dies by suicide. What is was like in the numb of back then.

The aftermath of Mottsu’s death was traumatic. There was shock and loss, and trying to tell his friends (our friends), colleagues, and family, his parents who lived overseas. There were too many people to tell. First round I rang, then calls came. I recounted what I knew over and over and I didn’t know much. It was a relentlessly demanding period. He was missing for four days before his body was found. It was a ghastly surreal period, trying to find him without knowing where to search, the tears, the police, the coroner, the funeral director… tears.

Then everything went quiet, I found myself alone. It was nowhere near Christmas and I kept thinking “…and all through the house. Not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse…” Hushed, I wrote the following few paragraphs while trying to absorb the force of the blow.

My life has slowed and I’m surrounded by what we had but not feeling a part of it. The funeral is done, the people are gone and the phone has stopped ringing. The remnants of our life together, furnishings and belongings, are inert and silent. The house is large and empty. Unnaturally still and quiet.

002 sit on the couch and breathe, not conscious of breathing. There are no eddies created by breathing in and out, the stillness is heavy, movement impossible. I just sit with the unnatural quiet in the eye of the storm trying to summon the resolve to move. Feeling like (I imagine) a quadriplegic person might feel, I grimace inwardly unable to summon a wiggle from a toe or a finger.

I have nothing to do and nowhere to go so I sit. I heard it’s possible to die of a broken heart. I know anecdotally of husbands and wives who follow each other to the grave, one unable to continue without the other. I wish it were possible to be absolved of the responsibility of going on. I could sit here and not move until even breathing stilled. Vanish, leaving just a crease on the couch to show where I sat. I could dissolve into the quietness and just not be anymore, without breaking the silence.

I can’t will it to happen and I continue to sit on the couch.

Going on will be hard but is indisputably my only option. Wishing myself away won’t provide an escape from reality. Still, sitting is as much as I can do. I shut my eyes to experience the quiet and open them. Again I close my eyes, there’s little difference no real change in state. Experimenting with my surrounds, I note that nothing else moves or changes. My eyelids open and close soundlessly while my limbs are heavy and unmoving. My mind is rendered useless and unable to anticipate time beyond the nest blink. There’s nothing that must be done, if I were to rise to my feet I wouldn’t know in which direction to step. The lethargy is like a dream that can be woken from.

Time is frozen too, it must be passing but there’s nothing to mark it. No ticking of a clock, no changing of the light through the glass. Eyes open or shut it’s the same day and maybe even the same minute. The world must be turning and it will continue to do so. It hardly seems to matter if I sit here as everything else will continue to go on. It feels like I’d not be missed in the world.

The refrigerator shudders and something inside it clunks, then there’s a ripping noise like an ice floe breaking from a glacier. It starts to hum and hiccough with mechanical tics. I sit, sphinx like listening to the fridge. I feel stuck, in a place akin to a tundra wasteland, unable to make the transition into starting a new life and unable reclaim the one I had.

It occurs to me that I am listening to the fridge. It seems a vaccuos thing to do, and a little funny and pathetic in a helpless sort of way. I don’t smile outwardly and continue to sit. There isn’t anything that has to be done. There isn’t anything I want to do and no one to do anything for.

The telephone slumbers, and a helicopter flies low overhead, its steady whirring blocking out the noise of the fridge. The spell is broken and time starts to tick again. I reconnect to reality and start to weep, for myself, for the inescapable horrors that exist in the world, for the uncertain future I face, for all that can’t just be willed away, and for the grumbling of my empty fridge.

Blind lexicographers

“I don’t know what to say….”

Countless people said, “I don’t know what to say….” (Idkwts)

I know you dkwts
I don’t know either. What is there to say?

Idkwts is an acknowledgment that there must be something to say to someone to someone who is mourning someone.

If only there were something more to say, I don’t think there is or if there is Idkwii (I don’t know what it is).

We were all blind lexicographers (a brilliant term I’ve shamelessly appropriated from a comment to an earlier post). I am so grateful to those who acknowledged my experience, I felt seen by the blind lexicographers who said “Idkwts…” I hope I replied with, at least, an appreciative mumble.

It was the mute lexicographers I struggled with, those who didn’t kwts and said nothing.
That hurt.

Hard to say and even more difficult to write about

I am a fan of the power of words and our use of language. The choice of words and their ordering can influence thinking and the perception of meaning. When describing how Mottsu died, for example, I struggled with the term committed suicide to describe how he died. Committed was the problem, to commit is to perpetrate a transgression. Suicide does violate fundamental moral views but acknowledgement of untreated depression as the major cause of suicide, supports more empathetic language.

I should also argue that those who knew the person who died are likely to feel that a transgression has been committed by virtue of the sorrow inflicted upon them. Even so it is simpler and less judgemental to say died by suicide.

A victim of suicide is, to my mind, is also a poor choice of words. However tragic or misguided a death is, the act of suicide is intentional over accidental. Built into the word victim is the insinuation that something is done to a person over which they had no control. I know suicide as a determined and planned act that is partly explained by being more feasible than the pain of another day.

The families and friends of someone who died by suicide (or a victim of suicide if you insist) are sometimes called suicide survivors. Just to set that record straight we are bereaved and bereft by the loss of someone we love. We may be survivors of the almost inevitable trauma experienced in the aftermath of a suicide, not suicide survivors.

Our vocabulary for death and dying is loaded with euphemisms that create meaning ‘between the lines’. Since Mottsu’s death I’ve found myself particularly sensitive to the meaning implied in our language of death.

Simple language can be considered brutal and choosing words carefully is desirable, difficult and greatly appreciated.

Darkness Visible

darkness visible A book about one man’s experience with depression that is honest, courageous and informing is Darkness Visible: A Memoir of Madness by William Styron

The preface:

For the thing which

I greatly feared is come upon me

and that which I was afraid of

is come unto me

I was not in safety, neither

had I rest, neither was I quiet:

yet trouble came.

- Job

“What I had begun to discover is that, mysteriously and in ways that are totally removed from normal experience, the gray drizzle of horror induced by depression takes on the quality of physical pain, like that of a broken limb. It maybe more accurate to say that despair, owing to some evil trick played upon the sick brain by the inhabiting psyche, comes to resemble the diabolical discomfort of being imprisoned in a fiercely overheated room. And because no breeze stirs this cauldron, because there is no escape from this smothering confinement, it is entirely natural that the victim begins to think ceaselessly of oblivion.” (Styron, 1990, p. 50 )

I have to thank my friend Charlotte, and her extensive collection of psychology related texts, for recommending Styron to me. I found it an extraordinary text. I am indebted to Charlotte, without this book I would have little appreciation for the mood disorder to which I lost Mottsu.

South Korean Model Daul Kim Found Dead In Paris

Another death by suicide and I am reconsidering whether I should continue to record high profile losses like Daul Kim. In trying to understand the state of mind that takes a person away, each instance offers a glimpse of the debilitating disorder depression can be, even so I am reconsidering…

I am also saddened that in the last month two people who knew people I know (two degrees of separation) chose death by suicide. Harrowing incomprehensible losses.

http://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2009/11/20/arts/entertainment-us-france-korea-model.html

From Daul Kim’s blog:

“…so what is my action.
jump out the window?
cut ur wrist?
party ?
be decadant?
do charity work?
be a housewife?
obey?
disobey?
prove? not prove?
love ? not love?
enjoy the power?
what power?
im not interested.
pretend to be interested?
i am not entertained.
then entertain yourself
i am not entertaintment
beat yourself with work
only cry for help when you are about to die
when you are on the floor
until no one cares
until not even yourself cares.”

POSTED BY DAUL AT 8:51 AM BLOG ENTRY 11 OCTOBER 2009

Displaced Anger

I am still pondering on Stage 2 of Grieving. The stage about Anger and Resentment, how I did and didn’t experience anger.

003
Dr Kubler Ross suggested that Stage 2 is characterized by fury at whatever caused the loss and that I might find myself enraged at the world. I don’t know about enraged with the world but there was a moment one evening when I was outraged/enraged by a friend of a friend. I think it was displaced anger, something undoubtedly well intended that the antagonist, Mikey, said ignited instant sparks of temper.

Mikey was someone I didn’t know very well, but had known over a long period. A friend of a couple of friends. In the early days of my aloneness he had suggested that it might be nice to catch up occasionally to go to the movies, an outing usually enjoyed more with a friend than on ones own. I was enthusiastic about the idea, I was keen for company, and Mikey would have been company. Time ticked by and we didn’t made it to the movies, one never made a call to the other.

The mutual friends, Mikey and I went to dinner one night. We dined well, we shared banter. I was a little tetchy and sensitive, it was becoming my modus operandi, wounded, prickly and defensive. 004Nonetheless we enjoyed the evening, but we didn’t linger. It was a work night, each had to get home.

We stood in the street to say our farewells. That’s when Mikey made his offer, in a moment of unprecedented and unparalleled chivalry Mikey asked if he could walk me to my car. Anger ignited and I held it in, smiled, shook my head, and walked away fuming. Furious with (possibly) displaced anger.

Here I was coping, grieving, taking my bins out on the right night of the week, alone, bereft, abandoned and often longing for company. Of all of the things Mikey could have offered to do, walking to my car was the least of them. I did it all the time, walked myself to my car, I mean, – a necessity.

He could have offered to change a light globe, clear the gutter of leaves, mow the grass, chat over lunch or go to the movies with me. Walk me my car? I was angry hurt and scornful, I haven’t seen those friends again. Long story, the loss of a player in our relationship(s) was too much, we didn’t ever recover (maybe it was me and my scatter gun approach to expressing anger).

I walk to my own car. I always did. I felt anger too, from time to time…

Where could 10,000 Frequent Flier points take you?

There are lots of obvious reasons for not mailing people who aren’t alive. Mottsu still gets regular mail from his Credit Union, his bookie, and a couple of vineyards whose mail lists he signed up for. He doesn’t respond, hasn’t for years, neither do I, and the letters keep coming… Apparently mail lists can take a while to catch up with departures.

He also gets gas bills, I don’t mind paying those after all there is no denying it’s me who uses the gas. I do mind that I can’t easily get the account transferred into my name. Some organisations make it difficult, wanting documentary evidence of a person’s passing. Do they even think about what it might be they’re asking for?

A death certificate can be a messy document. A death certificate lists the cause of death, as determined by the coroner. In this instance, at least, it’s truly more than the gas company needs to know. I don’t necessarily want the grim details of Mottsu’s demise on file at the gas company. Instead of me proving their customer is dead maybe they should prove he is alive – or do they take payment of his bills as proof? Perplexing.

I opt for the path of least resistance and leave the account in his name.

003 Recently an offer from a bank and an airline arrived. I think it was offering my dearly departed a credit card. The bank was one he didn’t bank with, so maybe the contact details were generated via the airline’s customer database. The envelope annoyed me so much that I didn’t open the letter, it still annoys me. The front of the envelope boldly asked “Where could 10,00 Frequent Flyer points take you?

I don’t know what perturbed me most about the question posed on an envelope addressed to a man who has been dead for over 5 years. I think it was the ridiculousness of the question; phrased to evoke a dream of flight, that angered me. I was exasperated, and wounded too, the junk mail came through the slot in the letter box and slipped right through my protective armour. Stupid unanswerable question…

I can’t reach him with a million Frequent Flyer points and I can not imagine where 10,000 points could take him. Honestly, I can’t imagine where he’d want to go if an airport were handy. Maybe the answer was inside the envelope, I didn’t look.

Anger, it seems I do have some tucked away.

Movember

Movember, encourages the growing of a moustache during November. For many men November has become Movember. It’s an awareness raining campaign, for two men’s health issues; prostrate cancer and depression.

It’s an overt display of a social conscience and I am unsure if the symbolism is hollow or significant. I am going to err on the side of ‘significant’, if awareness raising helps to reduce any of the social stigma associated with depression then Movember is a good thing.

movember

I have read on the campaign posters that 1 in 8 men will be affected by depression in his lifetime. There is a significant correlation between untreated depression and suicide.

Movember has me blogging and others talking, so I have to say that’s also a good thing. Whatever an individual’s motivation, mo-growers can deservedly feel virtuous. As for me. I am sporting a soft dark upper-lip fuzz, unsponsored and unpromoted, my own little gift of caring. Shhhh…. I feel smugly virtuous.

Stage 2

The second stage of grief as Dr Kubler-Ross describes it:

Anger and Resentment: “Why me?”
This stage is typically characterised by fury at whatever caused the loss and you may find yourself enraged at the world, at your higher power, at yourself, or at that which was lost. Nevertheless, this outcry should be accepted and not judged because it is part of the process of working through grief.

The second stage of grief as I experienced it:

Guilt and self recrimination: “I did it”
If you don’t really understand what happened (I don’t) and you’re left behind (I am) then it is sort of inevitable (I think) that you’ll feel a little responsible. There must have a thousand things I could have done to help him and maybe ten to save him. The guilt was punishing and I felt I deserved it. The beautiful life I had lived was gone. Endless rounds of counselling and therapy achieved small improvements and hoards of psychics were consulted for good measure. A future must be possible even if undeserved and I wanted a future.

Sadly the world at large look for your experience of anger as an indication that you’re progressing through the stages. “Are you angry yet?”

I was often asked that question and I did have to wonder what or who I would be angry with… Mottsu and his altered state? It was impossible to judge his actions by our everyday rational standards.

” Angry? Oh…. Do I have to be angry? Is it really required?”

I didn’t get angry, apologies Dr. Kubler-Ross.
Sorry Mottsu, I was never good at angry, and now what would it have changed?

Anger was just too hard, I didn’t have the resentment or the energy, and anger would have felt like blaming. I was determined not to blame…

I still hold that determination, without anger.

Numbed by Robert Enke’s suicide

Too sad:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/football/european_football/article6913198.ece

“It was a tough time. That is clear because he thought there was no hope of a recovery on the horizon for him.” said his widow.

Enke, who had played for clubs in Germany, Spain, Portugal and Turkey before settling at Hanover in 2004, winning eight full caps, had been treated by Valentin Markser, a therapist, for the past six years. “We were very close, yet even I didn’t notice how acute was the threat,” Markser said. “He knew how to hide the scope of his illness, had developed defence mechanisms….”