I have railed against the Stages of Grief, and thank my dear friend Charlotte for sharing a recent article; a meaningful analysis of the work of Dr Kubler-Ross and others on bereavement.
“Though Kübler-Ross captured the range of emotions that mourners experience, new research suggests that grief and mourning don’t follow a checklist; they’re complicated and untidy processes, less like a progression of stages and more like an
process—sometimes one that never fully ends.” Good Grief: Is there a better way to be bereaved? Meghan O’Rourke: The New Yorker, February 2010
For me the discussion in the article normalises an intense experience that brought out a personal, if at times crazed, response. When it comes to healing, we have an internal medicine cabinet stocked full of emotions to draw on. As you might expect when self-prescribing some responses might be considered less healthy choices. Be reassured, there is no right answer.
O’Rourke quotes Gorer who has noted a silencing of the mourner: “Today it would seem to be believed, quite sincerely, that sensible, rational men and women can keep their mourning under complete control by strength of will and character, so that it need be given no public expression, and indulged, if at all, in private, as furtively as . . . masturbation.”
Soused in grief I was bereft, bewildered and at times punchy. There were times I felt so disapproved of, I might as well have been masturbating in public. The ‘tuts’ and ‘tsks’ were palpable. It is good to recognise that the process is only as predictable as it is unpredictable, and not expect too much of others, or yourself.
To recap and align my own experience with the well known Stages of Grieving, looks a bit like this:
Stage 1
Dr. Kubler-Ross: Denial and Isolation: “This is not happening to me.”
Me: Realisation and weeping; “This is happening to me”
Stage 2
Dr. Kubler-Ross: Anger and Resentment: “Why me?”
Me: Guilt and self recrimination: “I did it”
Stage 3
Dr. Kubler-Ross: Bargaining: “Yes me, but. . .”
Me: Running away “Get me out of here”
Stage 4
Dr. Kubler-Ross: Depression: “Yes, me.”
Me: Depression: “Not me”
Stage 5
Dr. Kubler-Ross: Acceptance
Me: Emptiness
When dealing with loss, trust your own compass and make your own path through, grief is good. Complicated, untidy, ongoing, and good.
To my loved friends who stuck with me a warm and heartfelt thanks, it has been some trek. Namaste.